Reviews

2020 Shakespeare Challenge | May

Shakespeare

Hello and welcome to the fifth installment of my 2020 Shakespeare Challenge! If you would like some more details about the challenge you can find that in my post called,  Blogmas | Goals | 2020 Shakespeare Challenge. It feels so long since I started this challenge and I have found some I really loved and some I really didn’t enjoy. May was an interesting one fore sure. Before we jump into this review/discussion/rant I just want link to the goodreads group 2020 Shakespeare Challenge. And yes, I said rant this time around.


The Book

This months story The Taming of the Shrew. The title alone had me a bit apprehensive about this book, but my twitter followers picked it so I was going to follow through and read it. According to a quick search this was written around 1950.


My Review

I am going to honest, I am kind of torn on this one. This is really a cruel story in quite a few ways.  A well off man tricking a man into thinking he is a lord just for the fun of it. Taming a woman and making her not herself like she is an animal. Just all around manipulation in this book. I will say it was imaginative and like nothing I have read personally.

This starts off with a noble man of sorts feeling like they have so much power and influence they can just totally mess with someones life with fun. It put a really horrid taste in my mouth. I am really hoping Shakespeare was attempting to ridicule higher ups in society, if that was not the case I might actually hate him. The fact that this privileged person felt they could just do that was irritating and I was so irate while reading this. Everyone just went along with it like it was normal! I don’t understand.

Now the whole title of this play had me worried, like I mentioned earlier. Lexico describes one of the definitions of this word as “A bad-tempered or aggressively assertive woman.” I will also put forward when I hear the word tame, I think of a pet or animal, not a human being. So, I was kind of waiting for someone treating a lady as less than. Well, I was correct. The shrew in this story was treated like a jerk, only married to get her out of the way so others could marry her younger sister. While she was not nice I liked that she was strong willed and knew what she wanted. Well, her “husband” and I put it in quotations for a reason, he just was hired to marry her to get her out of the way treated her like garbage and manipulated her into being brainwashed and subservient. It honestly made me super mad and I hated every moment of this.

The more I write about this story and think about it, honestly the more I dislike it. Now, don’t get me wrong I know this was written around 1590, women had no place in society and her not seen as equals and it is apparent in many of Shakespeares plays where the father and husband have the final say and such, but I felt like this play just took it to a whole new extreme. IN the past plays I have read women were still allowed to be themselves and were not manipulated in the same manner and just seen as a creature that need to be moved out of the way so men could get to eh more desirable sister.

I really don’t want to say much more because I feel like this is already a rant. I really am hoping deep down that Shakespeare wrote the play with these two very troubling plot lines where two people are just totally manipulated as social commentary and didn’t just write it because it would be “fun” and “enjoyable”.


Next months pick is Twelfth Night, a huge thanks to those who voted in the poll!


Have you ever read The Taming of the Shrew? If so, what were your thoughts?

Sign Off 2020

Tumblr Twitter | Instagram | Goodreads

16 thoughts on “2020 Shakespeare Challenge | May

  1. I had a very similar impression on the play when I first read it, but when I studied it closer, I saw that it’s much more complex. Shakespeare really much explores themes of identity and role playing, showing how the role society thrusts on individuals influences their sense of self. Katherine isn’t a shrew by nature but those around her make her think she is by constantly calling her a shrew (just as Sly is made believe that he’s a lord). Petruchio, though his methods really seem brutal on the surface, helps her distance herself from this role. I don’t think Kate’s defeated in the end, but she’s become a clever player. I recommend watching 10 Things I Hate About You or the BBC Shakespeare Retold Episode on the Taming of the Shrew-both of which show brilliantly how Kate and Petruchio’s relationship is actually based on mutuality and love.

    Like

  2. Oh no! I hope you like Twelfth Night a lot more! I haven’t read this one but I feel like it would have been interesting to read in a classroom setting just to hear everyone’s opinions on it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I feel like that would have made a huge difference on how I perceived this book fo sure. I am still holding out hope that just missed the fact he was criticizing and poking fun at society and I just missed it.

      Like

      1. I liked the discussions with Romeo and Juliet because I learned it twice. Once in high school and once at university and got to see it live once. So there’s a lot of memories with that one but otherwise so far I liked Othello and A mid-sommers night dream. Hamlet and Macbeth blur together in my mind for some reason.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. That’s so strange! I feel like my class was pretty mature when we read it sr year of hs and we were all like why didn’t he wait and they were children and did we even get an age for Romeo etc. They were good discussions

        Liked by 1 person

  3. I can second that 10 Things I Hate About You is a great adaptation of this one (in the same way that Clueless is a great adaptation of Jane Austen’s Emma). It’s a satirical comedy about not acting how society wants you to act and being true to yourself, which I think is what Shakespeare was trying to get at in story – it just gets murky with the language and the societal norms of the 16th century.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s